Mosquitoes Worth Millions
Following a tip-off, ACF experts investigated a public procurement, worth BGN 1,063,955 VAT included, for GIS (Geographic Information System ) system to map mosquito populations along the Bulgarian bank of the Danube River. A number of violations were discovered.
The project was financed with European funding for transborder cooperation with Romania. The awarding authority was the Association of Danube River Municipalities “Danube”.
The findings of ACF’s experts show that the tender had been formulated in a manner allowing for a broad and subjective interpretation of the technical offers which carried the most weight when calculating the final scores of the candidates under evaluation. The tender was awarded to the company which offered the highest price with the company which qualified second offering a price some 30 percent lower.
Following the discovery of the above-mentioned violations, ACF decided to review the association’s ten largest public procurements worth a total BGN 3.8 mln. A number of violations were discovered:
– In all ten procedures contracts were awarded to the candidate offering the highest price, which was close to the estimated cost;
– Companies which came up second in the evaluation procedures offered significantly lower prices (usually 30-40% lower);
– In all procurement procedures, a large number of participants were disqualified, leaving just two candidates. This allowed the awarding authority to circumvent rule which says that if the average price offered by all other participants is 20 percent lower than the price offered by the winner, clarifications should be sought regarding the quoted prices;
– Despite the high projected costs, the requirements for the participants are very low, meaning that a company which had previously worked on projects worth BNG 1,000 could participate in a public tender worth BGN 1 mln.;
– There was no mechanism to control or dispute the candidates’ technical offers. At the same time, the difference in the evaluation scores of the companies is significant (for example 65 versus 8 points). This means that large differences between candidates after the technical evaluation stage could not be compensated by the review of the financial parameters;
– Projected costs diverging from market values.
On 21 June 2017, ACF sent reports to the Ministry of Regional Development and Public Works (MRDPW), the Bulgarian National Audit Office, the Executive Agency Audit of European Union Funds at the Ministry of Finance, Protection of the European Union Financial Interests Directorate at the Ministry of Interior, the Public Prosecution, and the European Anti-Fraud Office. On 19 July 2017, a report was also sent to the chief prosecutor of the National Anticorruption Directorate in Romania.
An investigation from 5 September 2017 by the Directorate General Territorial Cooperation Management at MRDPW discovered a number of violations, providing grounds for the imposition of financial corrections. On 6 November 2017, the directorate informed ACF about ten financial corrections on nice of the tender procedures. Subsequently, the association successfully appealed three of the financial corrections.
On 1 February 2018, ACF filed a report with the National Revenue Agency, which replied that an investigation has started. In January 2020, the revenue agency said the investigation had been completed without any findings of violations.
