ACF insists that a veto is put on the anti-corruption law

Following a round of critical arguments addressed to the bill, the Anti-Corruption Fund filed their stand to the President, too, with a clear motivation and a request for putting a veto on the newly-passed anti-corruption law. ACF generally assesses that the law, which has been passed, cannot effectively achieve the goals set, and at the same time it poses serious risks of violating the constitutional principles of the Rechtsstaat (i.e. the state of justice) and the separation of powers, on one hand, and the constitutional guarantees for the citizens’ rights and liberties, on the other, is stated in the stand that has been sent to the President. During the public debate, as well as within the parliamentary process, ACF expressed its expert stand twice with regard to the law. The fund’s critical recommendations, in addition to the suggestions of other independent expert organizations whose names have been recognized, were not taken into consideration. Even some additional negative suggestions were passed in the process of the legislative work to the detriment of the effective counteraction to corruption. The real anti-corruption milieu is created by the irreconcilable attitude of the citizens, the strong non-governmental sector, and the clear legislative framework. In this context, the Anti-Corruption Fund motivates not only the protection of the public interest, but also the meaningful legal arguments in this regard. The main conceptual criticism addressed to the law refers to the mechanical combination (within the framework of one institutional structure) of functions and activities that are too different in terms of their nature – administrative/punitive, identifying, operational/tracing, analytical, and preventive – however, it is exactly the investigative function that is missing here. The effective counteraction to corruption requires a definitive adequate investigation and collection of evidence that will serve subsequent penal proceedings. Without the existence of an institutional infrastructure, which can serve the counteraction to corruption, the law leaves us with a sense of complete ostensibility of the legal measure imposed. Furthermore, according to the law that has been passed, it turns out that corruption is above all a form of administrative violation (a conflict of interest), or ungrounded profiteering, instead of being a grave offence, which erodes the very foundation of the state governance. The stand reviews the following topics in particular: • The suggested procedure for electing a chairman and members of the committee – an election with a majority of the members present, conducted by the National Assembly. This objectively violates the independence of the organ and creates conditions for concentration and abuse of power. Thus the recommendations made in this regard (in a report concerning the Mechanism for Cooperation and Verification (CVM), published on 15 November 2017) are neglected. • The dropping out of existing forms of protection of the citizens sending the signals, in addition to the lack of conditions for the citizens and the organizations to cooperate with the organ in disclosing of corruption-related violations, which creates serious risks for their security due to the required full set of personal data. • The lack of sufficient guarantee for thoroughness upon filing the information regarding the ownership of legal entities, or other entities, which are registered in jurisdictions with preferential tax regime (offshore zones). This gives the indebted entities, that have registered offshore companies or have a share in the ownership and the management of offshore companies, absolute freedom to evade the legal requirements. The fund is asking the logical question: considering the above, how would the law be effective with regard to the publicity of the property of persons occupying high-level public positions? • The fact that the law neglects the recommendation of the January 2017 CVM report. The report explicitly recommends the reconsidering of the suggestion for disbanding the Committee for Confiscation of Illegally Obtained Property (Bulgarian acronym: KONPI) and uniting it with other organs. The new law creates serious risks for violating the citizens’ rights – without providing a legal mechanism with regard to the initially found discrepancy in the property acquired – to dispute before the independent court, prior to the start of the overall inspection procedure aiming to ascertain illegally obtained property.   • The stipulated employment of special intelligence means in conducting operational/tracing activities, which, in the context of such a multi-functional organ, creates prerequisites for concentration of power and possible abuse of that power that offends the citizens’ honour, reputation, and rights. The extended use of special intelligence means without sufficient guarantees for the citizens’ constitutional rights is yet another reason for putting a veto on the law that has been passed. In conclusion, ACF assesses that the establishment of a new “anti-corruption” organ just for the sake of it, without guaranteeing its independence from political influence and its public accountability, with a lack of guarantees for basic rights and liberties for the citizens, as well as with the fact that the established organ does not comply with the constitutional principles of the Rechtsstaat (state of justice) and the separation of powers, give the President sufficient grounds to exercise his constitutional right of putting a veto on the law. The fund officials express their readiness to attend a timely meeting with the President and to defend the arguments in response to the inceased public interest.

Subscribe to our newsletter!

By subscribing you confirm that you have read our Privacy Policy.

TIPP OFF

×

You will be redirected to an encrypted platform for submitting tips, in order to guarantee anonymity. Your IP address, the content of your message and any other sensitive information about the whistleblower that could be misused by third parties will remain fully hidden.

As a small expert organisation, we prioritise tips that contain sufficiently specific facts about corruption at least at the mid-level. Please describe all facts and data (names, addresses, dates, amounts, e-mails). Attach copies and/or originals of documents if you have any. Please be patient – our thorough approach takes time. We do not handle cases that concern solely private interests.

Scroll to Top